🔒 Safe State

Overview

@shined/react-use implements the useSafeState method for all internal state management operations. This method ensures that state updates are controlled and safe, especially in scenarios involving asynchronous operations or possible accidental component unmounting. It is designed to be a replacement for React.useState.

The behavior of useSafeState varies depending on the version of React used:

  • React 17 and earlier versions: Updates the state only when the component is still mounted. This behavior is achieved through the useUnmounted Hook. This method effectively suppresses the common React warning related to "setting state on unmounted components".
  • React 18 and later versions: Its functionality is the same as React.useState, following React's internal mechanisms to handle state updates on unmounted components more gracefully.

HandlingsetState Calls on Unmounted Components

There is a common misconception among developers that calling setState on an unmounted component will lead to memory leaks, but this is not the case.

This warning primarily serves as a reminder for developers to timely clean up related operations, such as timers and subscriptions, after the component is unmounted. In the lifecycle of the component, if setState is called after the component has been unmounted, it becomes a no-operation function (noop). Practically, this means such calls will be harmlessly ignored. Therefore, they will not cause memory leaks or trigger unwanted state updates.

According to discussion #82 of React 18, it points out that the future updates of React and the handling of state updates on unmounted components might undergo potential changes. The official statement indicates that "avoiding state updates on unmounted components" may be more problematic than "allowing these updates," implying that the best practices for state updates in future versions of React may shift.

Real-World Implications

Internally, @shined/react-use utilizes useSafeState in this manner to ensure compatibility and resilience in state management across different versions of React. By avoiding easily misunderstood warnings while also preparing for future changes in React versions, it guarantees the safety of state updates.